Hearing schedule
Download the complete schedule of the Marlborough Salmon Farm Relocations Advisory Panel independent hearings.
- Complete Schedule [PDF, 371 KB]
Presentations
Week 1 – 10 April
The whole of Government and expert planner's presentations from the 10 April public hearing are available to download. A Cawthron report on salmon farm effects on King shag has also been provided as supplementary material on the whole of Government presentation.
Whole of Government
Daniel Lees (MPI) and Frances Lojkine (MWH now part of Stantec), appearing for the whole of Government:
- Marlborough Salmon Relocation Proposal presentation [PDF, 1.6 MB]
- Cawthron – Review of salmon farm effects on King shag diet – 15 March 2017 [PDF, 398 KB]
- Expert planner's presentation [PDF, 174 KB]
- Expert planner's provisions table [PDF, 160 KB]
Week 1 – 11 April
Aquaculture New Zealand
Rebecca Clarke, appearing for Aquaculture New Zealand (AQNZ):
- AQNZ presentation [PDF, 329 KB]
- AQNZ additional extracts presentation [PDF, 513 KB]
- AQNZ overview of Colmar Brunton research [PDF, 1.2 MB]
- Colmar Brunton – Public perceptions of New Zealand's aquaculture industry – 14 Aug 2014 [PDF, 2 MB]
- MBA – SeafoodWatch Chinook salmon New Zealand report – 6 Nov 2014 [PDF, 883 KB]
- NIWA – Anthropogenic effects on marine habitats – 2012 [PDF, 5.2 MB]
- NZIER – Economic contribution of marine farming in Marlborough – Aug 2015 [PDF, 1.7 MB]
Individuals
- Gary Hooper's presentation [PDF, 2.8 MB]
- Lily McAnally's presentation [PDF, 131 KB]
- Rhea Hopkinson's presentation [PDF, 1.5 MB]
- Karen Mant's presentation [PDF, 469 KB]
Week 1 – 12 April
Marine Farming Association
Jonathan Bruce Large, appearing for Marine Farming Association (MFA):
- Marine Farming Association presentation [PDF, 367 KB]
Crail Bay Trust and Crail Bay Aquaculture Limited
Appearing for Crail Bay Trust and Crail Bay Aquaculture Ltd:
- Graeme Clarke [PDF, 1007 KB]
- Liz Clarke [PDF, 62 KB]
Apex Marine Farm Limited
Bruce Hearn, appearing for Apex Marine Farm Ltd:
- Apex Marine Farm Ltd presentation [PDF, 96 KB]
- RIAS Inc. – Comparing the environmental footprint of B.C.'s farm-raised salmon to other food protein sources – 11 Oct 2016 [PDF, 7.8 MB]
Individuals
- Clive Barker's presentation [PDF, 224 KB]
- Mark Preece's presentation [PDF, 1 MB]
Week 2 – 18 April
New Zealand King Salmon
Appearing for New Zealand King Salmon (NZKS):
- Andrew Clark part 1 – amended 1 May 2017 [PDF, 1.2 MB]
- Andrew Clark part 2 [PDF, 349 KB]
- Graeme Aldridge [PDF, 351 KB]
- Gascoigne Wicks [PDF, 701 KB]
- Grant Lovell part 1 [PDF, 469 KB]
- Grant Lovell part 2 [PDF, 1 MB]
- Grant Rosewarne part 1 [PDF, 409 KB]
- Grant Rosewarne part 2 [PDF, 2.6 MB]
- Jemma McCowan part 1 [PDF, 330 KB]
- Jemma McCowan part 2 [PDF, 8.3 MB]
- Lauraine Jacobs [PDF, 331 KB]
- Maree Cleal [PDF, 327 KB]
- Ruben Alvarez part 1 [PDF, 770 KB]
- Ruben Alvarez part 2 [PDF, 2.3 MB]
- Sunnie Pham part 1 [PDF, 335 KB]
- Sunnie Pham part 2 [PDF, 910 KB]
Week 2 – 19 April
New Zealand King Salmon
Appearing for New Zealand King Salmon (NZKS):
- Mark Gillard part 1 [PDF, 394 KB]
- Mark Gillard part 2 [PDF, 2.6 MB]
- Mark Preece [PDF, 520 KB]
Sanford Limited
Appearing for Sanford Ltd:
- Ted Cully [PDF, 619 KB]
Individuals
- Tony Black's presentation [PDF, 65 KB]
- Laurence O'Connell's presentation [PDF, 1.9 MB]
- Neil McLennan's presentation [PDF, 189 KB]
Week 3 – 1 May
French Pass Residents Incorporation
Laurence Etheredge, appearing for French Pass Residents Inc:
- French Pass Residents Inc part 1 [PDF, 92 KB]
- French Pass Residents Inc part 2 [PDF, 752 KB]
Clintondale Trust
David Whyte, appearing for Clintondale Trust:
- Clintondale Trust presentation [PDF, 838 KB]
Duncan Bay Residents Association
Christine Tuffnell, appearing for Duncan Bay Residents Association:
- Duncan Bay Residents Association presentation [PDF, 4.6 MB]
Individuals
- Peter Beech [PDF, 253 KB]
- Dr John and Judy Hellstrom [PDF, 561 KB]
- Penelope Gluyas [PDF, 366 KB]
- Penelope Gluyas' presentation – maps [PDF, 573 KB]
- Norm Gourdie [PDF, 186 KB]
- Jean Loomis [PDF, 408 KB]
- Jean Loomis’ presentation – Danny Boulton video [PDF, 280 KB]
- John Leader and Des Boyce [PDF, 489 KB]
Week 3 – 2 May
Marlborough Environment Centre
Bev Doole, appearing for Marlborough Environment Centre:
- Marlborough Environment Centre presentation [PDF, 5.1 MB]
- Marlborough Environment Centre presentation – Appendix 6 [PDF, 2.2 MB]
Individuals
- H Janssen [PDF, 1.5 MB]
- Peter Martin and Nikki Elliot [PDF, 13 MB]
- Vanessa and David Griffiths [PDF, 1021 KB]
- Frank Higgot and Susan Caldwell [PDF, 105 KB]
Week 4 – 8 May
Friends of Nelson Haven and Tasman Bay Inc. and Kenepuru and Central Sounds Residents Association Inc.
Appearing for Friends of Nelson Haven and Tasman Bay Inc (FONHTB) and Kenepuru and Central Sounds Residents Association Inc (KCSRA):
- Julian Ironside memorandum 1 [PDF, 233 KB]
- Julian Ironside memorandum 1 comments on legal advice [PDF, 1.2 MB]
- Julian Ironside memorandum 2 [PDF, 109 KB]
- Julian Ironside memorandum 2 attachments [PDF, 3.8 MB]
- Rob Schuckard part 1 [PDF, 435 KB]
- Rob Schuckard part 2 [PDF, 9.1 MB]
- Dr Michael Steven [PDF, 219 KB]
- Sylvia Allen [PDF, 645 KB]
- Hanneke Kroon [PDF, 629 KB]
- KCSRA supplementary statement [PDF, 155 KB]
Royal Society of Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand
Sally Gepp, appearing for Royal Society of Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand (Forest and Bird):
- Legal presentation [PDF, 685 KB]
Individuals
- Hanneke Kroon part 1 [PDF, 743 KB]
- Hanneke Kroon part 2 [PDF, 1.8 MB]
- Joop Jansen [PDF, 109 KB]
- Joop Jansen presentation photo [PDF, 319 KB]
Week 4 – 9 May
Environmental Defence Society
Rob Enright, appearing for Environmental Defence Society (EDS):
- Legal presentation [PDF, 710 KB]
- Further response [PDF, 724 KB]
- Adaptive management case note – SOS v KS (SC) [PDF, 487 KB]
McGuiness Institute
Wendy McGuiness, appearing for McGuiness Institute:
- Letter to Minister – 5 May 2017 [PDF, 6.3 MB]
- McGuiness Institute presentation – 9 May [PDF, 1.4 MB]
- Statement of evidence 5 May 2017 [PDF, 677 KB]
Individuals
- Katherine Saville-Smith [PDF, 846 KB]
- Martin Pinder [PDF, 9.3 MB]
- Martin Pinder attachment – NIWA and Leigh Marine Laboratory [PDF, 5.2 MB]
Week 6 – 17 May
Hui at Te Hora Marae
Te Ohu Kaimoana
- Laws Lawson – Map [PDF, 896 KB]
Ngāti Kuia
- Pakohe Management Plan [PDF, 2.8 MB]
- NIWA report: 1,000 year History of Seabed Change in Pelorus Sound [PDF, 3.2 MB]
Week 7 – 22 May
Marlborough District Council
The remaining presentations will be uploaded soon
- Gina Ferguson
- Dr Steve Urlich
New Zealand King Salmon
- Gascoigne Wicks response to fourth minute [PDF, 909 KB]
- Dr Niall Broekhuizen, NIWA – Light attenuation in Pelorus Sound in relation to foraging by king shag [PDF, 1.3 MB]
- Ben Knight, Cawthron – Review of potential light changes of relevance to King Shags from proposed salmon farming changes [PDF, 394 KB]
- Dr Colin Johnston – Fish health [PDF, 398 KB]
- Grant Lovell – Supplementary evidence [PDF, 316 KB]
Independent legal advice
- Richard Fowler QC – further advice 29 June [PDF, 3.4 MB]
- Richard Fowler QC [PDF, 2.2 MB]
- Richard Fowler QC – further advice [PDF, 1.5 MB]
Right of reply documents
Whole Government
Appearing for Whole of Government:
- Dan Lees – Right of Reply [PDF, 1 MB]
- DigsFish Services – Updated disease assessment report – 19 May [PDF, 27 KB]
Written transcripts
At presenter's requests, some minor technical amendments were made to ensure accuracy.
Week 1
- 10 April 2017 [PDF, 503 KB]
- 11 April 2017 [PDF, 586 KB]
- 12 April 2017 – as at 16 May 2017 [PDF, 583 KB]
Week 2
- 18 April 2017 [PDF, 788 KB]
- 19 April 2017 – as at 16 May 2017 [PDF, 882 KB]
Week 3
- 1 May 2017 [PDF, 843 KB]
- 2 May 2017 – as at 8 May 2017 [PDF, 1 MB]
Week 4
- 8 May 2017 [PDF, 816 KB]
- 9 May 2017 [PDF, 711 KB]
Week 6
- 17 May 2017 [PDF, 540 KB]
Week 7
- 22 May 2017 [PDF, 530 KB]
Expert witness meetings
Landscape – 3:00pm Tuesday 9 May 2017
- John Hudson – Hudson Associates Landscape Architects – Whole of Government (WoG) [PDF, 589 KB]
- Julia Williams – Drakeford Williams – WoG [PDF, 98 KB]
- Dr Michael Steven – Friends of Nelson Haven & the Kenepuru & Central Sounds Residents Association [PDF, 114 KB]
- Steven Brown – Environmental Defence Society [PDF, 387 KB]
Economics – 10:30am Wednesday 10 May 2017
- Bill Kaye-Blake – PwC – WoG [PDF, 130 KB]
- Andrew Clark – New Zealand King Salmon [PDF, 479 KB]
- Chris Money – EY – WoG [PDF, 56 KB]
- Wendy McGuinness – McGuinness Institute [PDF, 789 KB]
- Trevor Offen – Kenepuru & Central Sounds Residents Association and Pelorus Boating Club [PDF, 406 KB]
- Kevin Counsell – Environmental Defence Society [PDF, 700 KB]
King Shag – 10:30am Monday 15 May 2017
- Dr David Thompson – NIWA- WoG [PDF, 311 KB]
- Dr David Taylor – Cawthron Institute -WoG [PDF, 376 KB]
- Paul Taylor – Statfishtics – WoG [PDF, 361 KB]
- Graeme Taylor – DOC – WoG [PDF, 585 KB]
- Rob Schuckard – Friends of Nelson Haven and Kenepuru & Central Sounds Residents Association [PDF, 232 KB]
- Paul Fisher – Royal Forest and Bird Society [PDF, 659 KB]
